Mixed Cookies with 4 Flavors

Last Sunday, I had fun preparing some mixed cookies with different flavors. It was partly an experiment, but it turned out very well! All the cookies, of all four types, disappeared into my children’s mouths in a flash!

Unlike what I usually do, this time I didn’t use my classic shortcrust pastry (if you want to check out the recipe it’s here), but a variant of it, with only minor changes, which I then divided into four parts to get these (in my opinion, excellent 😊) mixed cookies.

They are ideal for afternoon tea, so if you’ve already made the tea… wait for me! I’m on my way!! 😀

〰 〰 〰

mixed cookies
  • Difficulty: Easy
  • Cost: Economical
  • Rest time: 30 Minutes
  • Preparation time: 30 Minutes
  • Portions: 70 Pieces
  • Cooking methods: Oven
  • Cuisine: Italian
  • Seasonality: All seasons

Ingredients

  • 1 1/4 cups self-raising flour
  • 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 6 1/3 tbsp butter
  • 1 egg
  • lemon zest (grated)
  • 1/4 cup shredded coconut
  • 2 tbsp unsweetened cocoa powder
  • 1 oz dark chocolate (or milk chocolate, I actually used 3 small chocolates)
  • 3/4 oz peanuts (shelled)
  • powdered sugar (for decoration, optional)

Tools

  • Bowl
  • Cutting Board
  • Rolling Pin
  • Grater
  • Baking Rack

Steps

  • Preparation of the shortcrust pastry
    I prepared the dough according to the same procedure as my classic shortcrust pastry, making only small changes to the ingredient quantities.

    Here’s how I proceeded:
    I poured the flours into a bowl and made a well in the center.
    I added the sugar, egg, and softened butter in pieces.
    I worked with my fingertips, pressing the butter and sugar well, gradually incorporating the flour. Initially, the dough, as always with shortcrust, crumbles, but then it blends well.
    I put the dough to rest in the refrigerator.

    This time, due to a commitment, I left it in the fridge for several hours instead of the usual half an hour: nothing happens, it just hardens a bit more, so after taking it out of the fridge, you have to wait about ten minutes to let it soften before working it.

  • I divided the dough into four parts. To each quarter of the dough, I added the specific ingredients: grated lemon zest, coconut, peanuts, cocoa, and chocolate.

    👉 In case you decide to make just one type of cookie, it would be more logical and convenient to add these ingredients directly into the dough, but in this case, I couldn’t do that. Also because, truth be told, the decision to differentiate the flavors came when the dough was already prepared. 😄 Proof of my theory that in cooking you can improvise, and sometimes you have to, and it’s the most fun part of cooking!

  • Preparation of the lemon cookies
    Of the four types of cookies, the lemon ones are the simplest to make.
    Work the dough with your hands to soften it a bit and roll it out with the rolling pin. Grate some lemon zest directly onto the dough, then knead again, roll it out again, and add more lemon zest. Roll it out to the desired thickness (I did about 1/5 inch) and, with a cookie cutter, in my case heart-shaped, cut out the cookies.

  • Preparation of the coconut cookies
    Work the dough with your hands to soften it a bit and add the coconut one tablespoon at a time. After adding each tablespoon, work with your hands to mix. The dough tends to crumble after the second tablespoon, but with a bit of patience, you win. I think you could also limit the coconut to three tablespoons, but I wanted the coconut flavor to be as evident as possible.
    Roll out the dough and, with a cookie cutter, in my case round, cut out the cookies (with this crumblier dough it’s a bit more difficult to roll it all at once).

  • Preparation of the peanut cookies
    Shell the peanuts and chop them with a knife.
    Work the dough with your hands to soften it and add the peanuts, proceeding more or less as already done for the coconut dough.
    Roll out the dough (any larger pieces of peanuts are pressed directly with the rolling pin) and, with a cookie cutter, in my case square, cut out the cookies.

  • Preparation of the cocoa and chocolate cookies
    Chop the chocolate with a knife.
    Work the dough with your hands to soften it and add the cocoa one teaspoon at a time. Hands get messy with cocoa: with this last dough, I recommend not working on a wooden cutting board but inside a container or on a steel board because cocoa stains a lot.
    After mixing the dough, add the chocolate pieces, proceeding as described for the peanuts, then roll out the dough and cut out the cookies with a cookie cutter. I used chocolates I had at home, but you can use any chocolate you prefer. Which chocolate do you prefer, dark or milk? 😊

  • Baking
    Place the cookies on the oven tray lined with baking paper. Bake at 300°F and cook for 10-15 minutes. There’s no difference in cooking among the four types of cookies. Once cooked, let the cookies cool on a baking rack.

    I was very satisfied with the result obtained, my mixed cookies disappeared in no time! 😋

    Let me know which of the 4 flavors is your favorite!

    mixed cookies

Follow me!

On my WhatsApp channel, on Instagram, on the Facebook page and Pinterest, in my two groups: Catia’s group, in the kitchen and beyond and  Just what I was looking for! and if you like… subscribe to my Newsletter.

On my WhatsApp channel, on Instagram, on the Facebook page and Pinterest, in my two groups: Catia’s group, in the kitchen and beyond and  Just what I was looking for! and if you like… subscribe to my Newsletter.

Author image

catiaincucina

The recipes from my home, simple and accessible to everyone. And all without added salt. If you want to reduce salt, follow me, I'll help you!

Read the Blog