Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

in

Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

​Discover the recipe for Colomba with Sicilian Cassata: the classic Easter cake meets the creamy heart of Sicilian tradition. Tips and tricks for a show-stopping and irresistible dessert.
 
​The perfect meeting of two icons of Italian pastry. Imagine the softness of the Easter Colomba encountering the creamy, baroque heart of the Sicilian Cassata. In this recipe, the soft leavened dough is hollowed out to hold a velvety sheep ricotta filling, enriched with chocolate chips and candied fruit.
​The cake is then fully covered with a white sugar glaze, just like the island tradition requires, and decorated with the vivid colors of candied citrus peel and candied cherries. A show-stopping and irresistible dessert, capable of bringing the Sicilian sun to your Easter table.​

For this recipe I used my homemade Colomba, click here to see my recipe.

Recipes chosen for you:

Colomba with Sicilian Cassata
  • Difficulty: Easy
  • Cost: Budget-friendly
  • Rest time: 2 Hours
  • Preparation time: 30 Minutes
  • Portions: 10
  • Cooking methods: Boiling
  • Cuisine: Italian
  • Seasonality: Easter Monday, Easter

Ingredients for the Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

Let’s go shopping

  • 26 oz colomba (whole cake) (about 26 oz (approx. 1 lb 10 oz))
  • 2 cups sheep ricotta (well drained (approximately 500 g))
  • 1 packet vanillin (vanilla powder)
  • 1 tsp orange blossom extract
  • 2 tbsp chocolate chips
  • 2 tbsp candied fruit (finely chopped)
  • 7 fl oz water (about 200 ml (about 3/4 cup))
  • 5 tbsp sugar (about 60 g)
  • 1 tsp orange blossom extract
  • 3 cups powdered sugar (sifted (about 350 g))
  • 2 tbsp water (30 ml (1 fl oz))
  • 1 tbsp lemon juice
  • to taste candied fruit (candied citrus peel, candied cherries, etc.)

Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

Tools to make Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

  • 1 Bowl
  • 1 Sieve
  • 1 Knife
  • 1 Pastry brush
  • 1 Saucepan
  • 1 Plate dessert plate

Steps to prepare Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

  • For this recipe it is important that the ricotta has been draining for at least one day so that no water remains in the basket.

    For this reason, since it will lose a lot of water, I recommend buying a little extra. Because by losing water, its weight will also decrease.

    Homemade Ricotta
  • Put the ricotta in a bowl, add the powdered sugar, the orange blossom essence and whisk quickly by hand (do not use an electric whisk).
    Once the mixture is smooth and homogeneous, pass it through a sieve with the help of a spatula. Never whip it with beaters otherwise it will become watery.

    ricotta cream
  • Do not remove the colomba from its lateral paper mold. Only remove the paper on the base.

    Turn it upside down, and cut the bottom.
    The lateral paper should be kept.
    Begin to hollow it out.

  • Chef’s tips: how to hollow out the Colomba without breaking it
    ​Hollowing out a large leavened cake may seem delicate, but with these precautions it will be very simple:
    ​The fridge trick: Before starting, place the colomba in the refrigerator for about 30-60 minutes. The cold compacts the dough fibers, making it firmer and less likely to crumble while you cut it.

    Colomba with Sicilian Cassata
  • Choose the right tool: use a long serrated knife (bread knife).

    First cut the perimeter leaving a border of about 2 cm (about 3/4 inch), then make cross cuts inside to extract the crumb in cubes more easily.
    ​Do not throw anything away, because the crumb will be mixed with the ricotta cream to give more structure to the filling.

  • Once you have hollowed out the colomba prepare the soaking syrup. Heat the water and sugar in a small saucepan, stirring constantly until the sugar has completely dissolved; let it cool and add the orange blossom extract.

    syrup for soaking
  • Lightly moisten the inside of the colomba with a pastry brush, and break the colomba crumbs you cut into rough pieces with your hands.

    Colomba with Sicilian Cassata
  • Start filling the colomba:
    Place a few spoonfuls of ricotta inside, some of the crumbs, candied fruit or chocolate chips.

    Colomba filling
  • Continue in layers until all the ingredients are used.

    Colomba layering
  • At the end, insert the base as if it were a plug in the bottom of the colomba, place the colomba on a plate and, in this position (upside down), put it in the refrigerator for at least 1 hour. Meanwhile prepare the royal icing following the directions.

    Colomba chilling
  • For a perfect glaze (called in Sicily “fondente” or “naspro”), put the water, sugar and lemon juice in a bowl. Mix until you obtain a fairly dense mixture.
    ​If it is too runny, add sugar; if it is too stiff, a few drops of water.

  • Pour it starting from the center of the colomba and let it naturally flow down the sides to evenly cover the cold surface and decorate before it dries.
    Wait about thirty minutes for the glaze to begin to set but while it is still soft, you can have fun decorating it with candied fruit.

  • ​The Triumph of Candied Peel: Cut the candied peel into thin strips or small diamonds.

    Place them as you like, creating a floral pattern that stands out on the white glaze.

  • The Touch of Color: Lay whole or halved candied cherries at the intersections of the candied peel. The bright red will create the perfect contrast with the green of the peel and the whiteness of the sugar.
    ​The Final Detail: If you want to go over the top, add a few strips of candied orange peel.
     

  • When you have finished, store the Colomba with Sicilian Cassata in the refrigerator until needed. But take it out about thirty minutes before serving.

    Here is the Colomba with Sicilian Cassata, ready to serve.

    Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

Storage

The Colomba with Sicilian Cassata keeps in the refrigerator for up to 2-3 days, stored in an airtight container to prevent the glaze and cake from absorbing odors from other foods.

​Being a dessert made with fresh ricotta, it is essential not to keep it at room temperature for more than one hour. I recommend removing it from the fridge about 15-20 minutes before serving, so the cream softens and releases all its aroma without compromising food safety.

Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

FAQ (Questions and Answers)

Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

Colomba with Sicilian Cassata

Author image

ritaamordicucina

The cooking blog Rita Amordicucina offers a wide range of recipes, with a particular focus on the cuisine of Northeastern Sicily and Messina. It specializes in fish recipes, pastries, and diet dishes, demonstrating how one can eat deliciously while maintaining a healthy weight. Its motto, "Do what you can with what you have, wherever you are," reflects its desire to teach cooking with limited resources. In addition to the blog, it has participated in television shows and food festivals.

Read the Blog